GAMMA-Rayv0.0.1 · draft

A draft standard · Graph-Analyzed Multi-framework Maturity Assessment with Risk-Adjusted Yield

The more an agent is governed, the further it can be trusted to go.

GAMMA-Ray rates one AI agent on two things: how much it does on its own, and how well that is controlled. It asks 21 questions. Each answer needs evidence, and each answer counts towards several published standards at once.

9instruments read at source
286provisions, one statement each
69indicators, one observable fact each
21questions

Two levels, one result

Freedom is what the agent does on its own, from 1 (it answers) to 5 (agents working with agents). Governance is how it is controlled, from 0 (nothing stated) to 4 (proven). An agent is held at the highest freedom level that its governance supports. A small agent that is well governed is mature. A powerful one that nobody can show to be controlled is not, yet.

Freedom 1, governance 0: heldFreedom 2, governance 0: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 1Freedom 3, governance 0: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 1Freedom 4, governance 0: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 1Freedom 5, governance 0: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 1Freedom 1, governance 1: heldFreedom 2, governance 1: heldFreedom 3, governance 1: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 2Freedom 4, governance 1: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 2Freedom 5, governance 1: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 2Freedom 1, governance 2: heldFreedom 2, governance 2: heldFreedom 3, governance 2: heldFreedom 4, governance 2: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 3Freedom 5, governance 2: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 3Freedom 1, governance 3: heldFreedom 2, governance 3: heldFreedom 3, governance 3: heldFreedom 4, governance 3: heldFreedom 5, governance 3: reaches further than its governance supports; held at 4Freedom 1, governance 4: heldFreedom 2, governance 4: heldFreedom 3, governance 4: heldFreedom 4, governance 4: heldFreedom 5, governance 4: held0 Unstated1 Stated2 Owned3 Bounded4 Proven1 Answers2 Suggests3 Acts4 Acts widely5 CoordinatesFreedom: what the agent does on its own →Governance: how it is controlled →PrompTugalRiskMandate P…

This is RiskMandate's lens, measured: freedom is the agent's reach, governance is its mandate and what stands in the way, and the distance between the level reached and the level held is the gap.

One short list, many standards

Maturity standards for agents ask many of the same things in different words. We cut 9 instruments into 286 provisions, found the observable fact behind each, and grouped those facts into questions. 215 of the 286 provisions (75%) are reached by 21 questions. The rest are listed as outliers: what only one instrument asks.

Provisions read, in 9 instruments286Provisions that a question reaches215Indicators: one observable fact each69Questions21

Where this is

A draft, v0.0.1. The mapping between instruments is a first pass by one reader and has not been checked by a second. So far it rates nobody but ourselves. What exists and what does not.